Stalker’s Delight

People sometimes wonder why I pick on–“stalk”–Jason Brennan so much. The answer is that I like wringing concessions out of his arrogant ass, and often get exactly what I’m looking for.

Like this:

UPDATE: I modified this slightly, because I realized that I don’t know what Krugman thinks about trade all-things-considered. 

No, I don’t mean the claim about Krugman. I mean the hyper-conscientiousness Brennan now shows about alerting his readers to the substantive changes he makes in his posts for 200-Proof Liberals. Remember when, at BHL, he self-righteously asserted the prerogative to write and re-write and re-write and re-write his posts without notice so as to evade criticisms? I do, and so does everyone who read the site. Now, without further ado, he’s forgotten all his “arguments” on that issue, and changed course by 180 degrees. Conscientious Brennan now makes sure to tell us when he’s made substantive changes.

What accounts for the reversal? Two hypotheses:

  1. He did it out of a sense of pure conscientiousness and intellectual integrity, the virtues consistently on display in all of his posts.
  2. He did it because I repeatedly made him look like a fucking asshole for writing posts and then changing them without notice, embarrassing him in public at the price of being defamed by him and his friends.

I’ll leave that one as an exercise.

Turning over a new leaf, huh, Jason? Hey, every day is a winding road. So keep it up. You’re getting a little closer–to ordinary decency.

2 thoughts on “Stalker’s Delight

  1. I recently revised a post of mine on this very site, because it contained a howling error. No one else noticed the error, though. Or at least no one commented on it. And I did put up a “revised” notice. The post was cross-listed on BHL and my own blog as well, and I revised it in those places too. I wasn’t sure whether I’d be able to log into BHL, but it turns out I can!


    • Yes, what Matt Zwolinski said was that they (the BHL bloggers) would no long post new content, but that the old content would be archived. He didn’t say anything about closing comments (or even the blog itself), and after all, his own post announcing “The End” got comments for a month or two after he posted. So BHL was never fully closed down.

      Apropos of that, I leave you (plural) to guess what happened in this thread, responding to Zwolinski’s last BHL post:

      Irfan Khawaja • 6 months ago
      Despite my sometimes acrimonious disagreements with people at this blog, I sympathized with the original idea behind it, and learned a lot from it over the years. I’d say that BHL accomplished much that it set out to do. Thanks for creating and maintaining it.



      Share ›
      This comment was deleted.

      Irfan Khawaja Guest • 6 months ago
      Always happy to oblige.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s